Netflix’s The Lincoln Lawyer has captivated audiences with its intricate legal dramas and the compelling character of defense attorney Mickey Haller. Each season masterfully blends overarching narratives with episodic cases, keeping viewers on the edge of their seats. Season 3 concluded with a dramatic cliffhanger, the death of Sam Scales, a recurring character with a dubious past and a connection to Mickey Haller. This shocking event not only sets the stage for The Lincoln Lawyer season 4 but also raises crucial questions about who Sam Scales truly was and the circumstances surrounding his untimely demise, especially when considering Michael Connelly’s source material.
Who is Sam Scales? A Deep Dive into Mickey Haller’s Problematic Client
Sam Scales is introduced early in The Lincoln Lawyer as one of the clients Mickey Haller inherits when he takes over Jerry Vincent’s law practice. From the outset, Scales is portrayed as a liability, a con artist masquerading as a benefactor of the underprivileged. His true nature is quickly revealed: Sam Scales is a man driven by self-interest with a blatant disregard for ethics and the well-being of others.
In The Lincoln Lawyer season 1, the audience learns about Sam Scales’ fraudulent activities when he is prosecuted for running a fake charity. He solicited donations under the guise of funding cancer research, a cause that tugs at heartstrings, only to pocket the money for personal luxuries. Instead of contributing to cancer research, donations funded his extravagant purchases, including a commercial-grade espresso machine and a Rolex watch. This initial scam demonstrates the depth of his deceit and his willingness to exploit noble causes for personal gain.
[
]
Sam Scales’ scams are not isolated incidents; they are a pattern of behavior. Even while facing legal repercussions for his initial fraud, he brazenly operates another fake charity, Homes4Youth.com, presumably preying on the goodwill of people wanting to support foster children. His audacity is further showcased when he is later found soliciting funds outside a grocery store for service animals for veterans, another vulnerable group easily targeted for exploitation. Throughout these schemes, Sam Scales consistently evades his financial obligations, owing money to Mickey and other characters within the Lincoln Lawyer universe.
Despite his repeated offenses and lack of remorse, Lorna and Cisco attempt to leverage Sam’s skills in season 2. They propose a deal: create a website for them in exchange for wiping out one of his debts. However, Sam remains uncooperative, unwilling to fulfill his financial responsibilities. By season 3, Sam Scales finds himself in jail once again, embroiled in yet another scam. This time, he collects money for grocery gift cards for striking workers. While he surprisingly donates a portion of the funds to the intended cause, he keeps the majority – two-thirds of the raised money – for himself, showcasing his inherent greed even when engaging in seemingly altruistic endeavors. His extensive list of aliases, including Samuel Scales, Benny Bates, Francois DuPont, Daniel Varela, Gunther Schmidt, Vincenzo D’Aramo, and Walter Lennon in the books, further highlights his life built on deception and evasion.
The Events Leading to Sam Scales’ Demise in Season 3
The narrative arc of Sam Scales takes a dark turn in The Lincoln Lawyer season 3, culminating in his death. After Lorna represents him in court in episode 7, “Relevance,” Sam has a heated exchange with Mickey outside the courthouse. A deal is struck where charges will be dropped if Sam repays the stolen money. However, Sam claims he cannot repay, stating he owes the money to someone who would kill him if he doesn’t pay. In a moment of frustration and anger, Mickey retorts that Sam Scales will face dire consequences, implying death, if he fails to pay the law firm what he owes.
[
]
Mickey’s statement, though made in hyperbole and professional frustration over the mounting debt – Sam already owed $25,000 plus interest – becomes chillingly prophetic. In the dramatic conclusion of The Lincoln Lawyer season 3, Sam Scales is discovered dead in the trunk of Mickey’s car. This grim discovery not only serves as a shocking cliffhanger but also sets up the central conflict for season 4, directly adapting Michael Connelly’s novel, The Law Of Innocence, the sixth book in The Lincoln Lawyer series.
Connecting Sam Scales’ Death to “The Law of Innocence” and Season 4
Michael Connelly’s The Law Of Innocence provides the crucial context for understanding the true circumstances behind Sam Scales’ murder and why Mickey Haller finds himself framed. In the book, Mickey discovers that Sam Scales was killed by Louis Opparizio, a powerful and ruthless mob boss. Scales had run a scam involving the fraudulent collection of funds for converting used cooking oil into biofuel. Unbeknownst to Scales, his scheme targeted Opparizio’s organized crime syndicate, resulting in significant financial losses for the mob boss.
Seeking retribution for being swindled and to settle an old score, Opparizio not only eliminates Sam Scales but also masterminds a plan to frame Mickey Haller for the murder. Opparizio plants Scales’ body in the trunk of Mickey’s Lincoln and arranges for Mickey to be pulled over, ensuring his arrest and implicating him in the crime. In The Lincoln Lawyer series, Louis Opparizio is adapted into the character Alex Grant, who was previously a suspect in the Mitchell Bondurant case in season 2. While Alex Grant seemed to have moved on after season 2’s events, the finale of season 3 reveals his lingering grudge against Mickey Haller and his willingness to go to extreme lengths for revenge.
Sam Scales’ death and the subsequent framing of Mickey Haller propel the narrative into The Law of Innocence storyline for The Lincoln Lawyer season 4. Mickey, now facing the most daunting legal battle of his career, must defend himself against a murder charge, navigating a complex web of deceit and danger orchestrated by a vengeful and powerful enemy. Season 4 promises to be Mickey Haller’s ultimate test, forcing him to utilize all his legal acumen and street smarts to prove his innocence and expose the true killer.
